 
1) Roof
Damage Building Permit Lawsuits
What are the
lawsuits about?
The Hurricane Law Group has commenced separate class action lawsuits against Allstate
Floridian Insurance Co. (Allstate), Citizens Property Insurance Corp.
(Citizens) and State Farm Florida Insurance Co. (State Farm) on
behalf of Floridians whose homes were insured by these providers during the past five
years and who suffered roof damage caused by a hurricane or other natural disaster. The
lawsuits allege that Allstate, Citizens and State Farm failed to pay and/or properly
adjust claims in Florida by ignoring requirements to obtain a building permit prior to
commencing roof repair or replacement. The suits further allege that as a result of this
failure policyholders were under-compensated for their losses.
Please click here for a PDF copy
of the Allstate suit
Please click here for a PDF copy of
the Citizens suit
Please click here for a PDF copy of the
State Farm suit
What insurance companies were sued?
Allstate Floridian Insurance Company and Allstate Floridian Indemnity Company
Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
State Farm Florida Insurance Company
Who is affected by the suits?
If you were paid for roof damage for a hurricane, tornado or other natural disaster claim
by the above named insurance companies over the last five years, you may be affected by
the suit. No class has yet been certified in the lawsuits. To be a member of the proposed
class, you need not take any action at this time. You may retain counsel of your choice.
How can I find out more about the lawsuits?
If you wish to discuss these lawsuits, participate in this or any other lawsuit, or have
any questions please contact attorney Paul Berger via email paul@hurricanelawgroup.com, by calling
1-888-FLA-CLAIM, or by completing the form below.
2) Hurricane Wilma Class Action Lawsuit
What is the lawsuit about?
If you live in Miami-Dade or Broward County and sustained window damage during Hurricane
Wilma, you were required by the Florida Building Code to replace your damaged windows with
impact glass or a standard window plus a hurricane shutter.
The suit alleges that Citizens Property Insurance Corporation (Citizens)
failed to pay and/or properly adjust Hurricane Wilma claims in Broward and Dade County by
ignoring the Florida Building Code and its requirements with regard to the replacement of
windows and other glass structures. This failure occurred when Citizens paid policyholders
for simple glass replacement instead of the impact glass or glass plus shutters as
required by the Florida Building Code. Click
here to download a PDF of the lawsuit.
Background
The Florida Building Code (FBC) is a legacy of Hurricane Andrew, which caused
approximately $30 billion in property damage as it swept across southern Florida in 1992.
Before Andrew, the response to storm damage had been to clear away the debris and build
again. After Hurricane Andrews winds leveled Homestead and other cities in its path,
taxpayers and the insurance industry questioned the practice of just build
again. As a result, the countrys toughest building codes were adopted in
southern Florida.
The changes, incorporated into the 1994 code, were designed to address the weaknesses
associated with the building envelope that became evident after a major storm. The three
main areas of building construction weakness (roof systems, opening protection, and roof
sheathing attachment) were identified and hurricane mitigation provisions were considered.
Ultimately, the improved structural provisions were incorporated from the South Florida
Building Code into the Florida Building Code as the High Velocity Hurricane Zone
(HVHZ) provisions, which are applicable in Broward and Dade Counties.
The HVHZ imposes substantial requirements upon individuals seeking to make repairs to
windows and sliding doors after a hurricane has damaged the glass structures of a
building. Indeed, simple glass replacement is virtually impossible in HVHZ areas following
a hurricane.
Who is affected by the lawsuit?
The suit was filed against Citizens Property Insurance Corporation on behalf of Dade and
Broward County Citizens policyholders. If you are a Citizens policyholder and filed
a Hurricane Wilma claim, you may be affected. Suits against other insurance companies are
being planned.
How can I find out more about the suit?
If you wish to discuss this action, participate in this or any other lawsuit, or have any
questions please contact attorney Paul Berger via email paul@hurricanelawgroup.com, by calling
1-888-FLA-CLAIM, or by completing the form below.
|